A few months ago I started being better about only allowing Ethan to have a binky at nap time. Although we didn't know when we were going to take the binky away we did tell him a few times that we were going to have to take it away soon. We also told him that we would buy him a lego set after he had gone a whole week without a binky, more as a way of saying good job and congratulations than as bribery. I thought the hardest parts would be sleep time (of course) and church (where we also let Ethan use a binky to keep him calm). I knew I wanted take them away on a Monday so that they had as long as possible to adjust before church. Logan was never really attached. He slept with it sometimes but mostly he liked to have it while in his car seat (because he hates his car seat). Two weeks before we took it away Logan got a little cold and he started using a binky more often. Then the week before we took them away I noticed that Logan was finding binkies and putting them in his mouth for the first time. He normally just played with them in his hands but when I saw him starting to always put it in his mouth I started to get worried about him getting addicted to his binky. Plus Ethan was begging for his constantly and I did not like that. I figured Ethan would never nap again but I decided I would have to learn to live with that. On Sunday, December 30th I made a last minute decision and told Ethan that it was his last night with a binky. I don't think he believed me although he did cry in protest for a little bit. He asked me why so I told him that the binky was hurting his teeth and the doctor said he needed to be done with using a binky. The next morning I took hid all the binkies. Ethan asked for it briefly a couple times in the morning but I told him they were gone. I don't think he was really listening. Logan cried for an hour during his first nap and then slept for less than 30 minutes. My heart was breaking. This was going to be harder than I thought. But I knew I couldn't stop now. Then the next time I tried to take them away it would be even harder. I actually gave him his binky for his second nap so that he wouldn't get too overtired. But that was the last time. I didn't even attempt to put him down for a nap because I knew there would be crying. During the middle of his normal nap time he started crying for his binky. I told him that there were no more-that Daddy had taken both his and Logan's binkies to work and thrown them away. And that there would be no more binkies. He cried for only a minute or two and I mourned with him (hey, this was hard for me too! Those were my go-to calming devices!). I almost started crying and told him that I knew it was hard that that he was so strong and could do it. I said I was sorry repeatedly. I realized when he calmed down quickly that he really appreciated me being sad with him. He didn't mention binkies again until bedtime. Logan cried for 30 seconds at bed time. I don't think he has even noticed at all since then. We knew Ethan would have a hard time going down so instead of trying to put him down we just let him crash. We got him ready for bed as normal but we told him he could keep his light on and play for as long as he wanted. He came out crying just a few times, and he came out excited to show us what he was doing a few times as well. At one point when he was crying he said, "I want to buy more binkies." I told him that we were going to go a whole week first and then maybe we would buy more. Trent got upset about that, but I told him that I just felt like I didn't want Ethan to feel like it was the end of the world. I wanted him to have hope he would sleep easily again. Finally after 10:00 PM he crashed. No more crying. I was amazed. That was a lot less crying on the first day than I would have anticipated even in my most optimistic of dreams. I think the key was that Logan wasn't too addicted yet and that Ethan knew there were no more in the house. If Logan had still had his binky I am sure that Ethan would have just begged for one of his. This way he had to accept that there was literally no way to get one.
The next two days were about the same. I think the third day was the hardest. He would ask me periodically for his binky and each time I would give him a sincere hug and tell him I was sorry; there were no more binkies. Ethan was getting progressively more tired each day but I knew he would catch up later. Then, on Friday he did something totally unexpected. He put himself down for a nap. Then again on Saturday and Sunday! The worst of it was over and it hadn't even been that bad! Whew!
We, of course, have had him ask for a binky a few times after that (and he may have briefly cried for 3 seconds or so) but mostly he has been fine. It's funny because sometimes it is ME that wants to grab one for him or Logan even though I can see that they are doing fine without it. I am so thankful that it went so well.
This is the last picture I have of both of them with their binkies. Brotherly love ;).